BF Goodrich Tires: Are They Worth It? (12 Brands Compared)
BF Goodrich is the oldest tire brand, and in the past 150 years, you expect them to know a thing or two about what makes a tire work.
What Tires Are Available in the Goodrich Range?
Depending on your vehicle, you can get the following:
- Off-road tires – two offerings: all-terrain T/A KO2 or the mud terrain T/A KM3
- On-road – 12 choices.
- Load carrying – more specialized tires.
- Performance.
- Winter.
- Summer.
- All-terrain.
- Electric vehicles.
- Energy saving greener tires.
The on-road tires include:
- G-Force Winter2
- Advantage All-Season
- Advantage SUV All-Season
- G-Grip All-Season2
- G-Grip All-Season2 SUV
- Advantage
- Advantage SUV
- Activan 4S
- Urban Terrain
- Radial T/A
- G-Force Winter2 SUV
- G-Force Winter
The performance across the range is similar, with an external noise rating of 69 dB, fuel efficiency score D (categories A-E), and middle-of-the-road wet grip classification in the middle of the rankings.
Specific tire ranges in the collection may offer slightly different features.
The winter tires have a soft rubber formulation, and the Advantage All-Season tires have a handy tread wear indicator, so you get a visual check that your tires are balanced.
What Makes BF Goodrich Tires Worth Buying?
Tires from leading brands meet all the necessary road safety standards.
The top reasons for buying BF Goodrich tires include the following:
Oldest Known Tire Brand
Founded in 1870, Goodrich has over a century’s worth of experience in tire development.
Goodrich supplies tires for off-road sports and racing drivers.
Their research and development are ongoing, and BF Goodrich is an early adopter of new technology flowing innovations to the tires you put on the family car.
Affordability
Compared with other tires, BF Goodrich is affordable and provides adequate and consistent performance for daily driving.
You can get better-performing tires on the market, but if you want affordable, reliable tires for winter, all-season, and all-terrain tires, the BF Goodrich range can meet your needs.
Wide Range
Goodrich provides tires to fit different conditions and vehicles in a broad range of rim sizes. You can get a BF Goodrich tire, whatever your vehicle or driving needs on or off-road.
You have plenty of winter options if you need one set of tires for winter that stays pliable and functioning in extreme snow.
The all-season tire will still perform in severe snow but performs marginally better in wet conditions.
If your driving takes you off-road, you can get a tire that gives better traction on challenging terrains.
US Manufacture
BF Goodrich tires are not entirely all-American manufactured, but BF Goodrich maintains three manufacturing plants in the US.
You can check the tire code to find out if your brand of Goodrich tire came from one of these three plants.
Components and raw materials may come from outside the US, but a selling point for BF Goodrich is that despite its ownership by a French company (Michelin), it maintains work in the US.
Excellent Reputation
BF Goodrich supplies tires for all the major off and on-road sports events and has a long history in performance driving.
You may not want to take the family car off-road, but the technology developed to cope with challenging terrains benefits standard road tires.
If you want to take your vehicle off-road, choose the appropriate all-terrain tire. If you stick to smooth road surfaces, choose a well-mannered tire developed with that surface, like the Advantage.
Consistent Performance
Although BF Goodrich tires don’t score at the top of the ratings in any category, the tires provide consistent performance in the middle across all types of road noise, braking, fuel economy, and grip.
You get a decent all-around performer rather than an expensive superstar in one category. For most drivers, consistent performance across the board is better value for money.
Warranty
All the tires in the BF Goodrich range have a manufacturer’s warranty that covers defects in construction for the earlier of:
- Useable tread; or
- Six years.
Some individual tires have a tread warranty varying between 50,000 and 75,000 miles depending on the type.
In practice, you are unlikely to claim under a tread warranty for any tire because the claim is pro-rated, and there are plenty of conditions attached to driving, care, and treatment of the tires.
Tire Registry
After purchasing new BF Goodrich tires, you can register your tires to receive updates in case of any tire recalls.
Tire recalls for safety reasons are rare, but receiving an instant notification is better than being unaware of a potential issue with your tires.
Accessible
Most places in the US stock BF Goodrich tires and have speedy ordering if your size is currently not in stock.
Readily available tires are a positive advantage in scheduling services and keeping you motoring.
Why Are BF Goodrich Tires So Expensive?
All tires are expensive, but BF Goodrich tires are affordable compared to other tire bands.
Reasons why BF Goodrich tires cost so much include:
Made in the USA
A significant proportion of BF Goodrich tires are produced in North America, where the labor costs are significantly more than in China and other parts of the world.
To some extent, you pay a premium for supporting a US manufacturer, and the same tire produced in China may cost less.
However, keeping the manufacturer in the USA supports the local economy and maintains a competitive edge in research and development.
Research and Development
BF Goodrich spends a significant amount on research and testing different tread patterns, rubber formulations, and other technology to provide you with a better road tire.
The cost of that research goes into the final price of the tire you buy for your vehicle.
Complex Manufacture
There are six main components in a Goodrich tire: the inner liner, crown plies, tread, carcass ply, beads, and a strong sidewall.
The complexity of features and the layers involved in construction (a mixture of cords, rubber, and technical fabrics) increase the base cost of tires.
Cheaper tires involve less complex manufacture but wear more rapidly and don’t provide the same high-quality driving experience.
Reduced Road Noise
Making a quieter tire costs more than the hard and noisy rubber previously used.
BF Goodrich is middle of the road for road noise at 69dB, but these are still quiet tires and hence more expensive to produce.
Longer Lasting Tread
Drivers want tires that last for many miles. From the manufacturer’s viewpoint, the economy means fewer sales for them.
A tire that lasts will cost fractionally more than a tire you need to change more frequently.
How many miles you get from your tires depends on factors like road surface and driving style, but it is a fine calculation to work out value for money in having a tire that lasts longer rather than frequent tire changes.
A tire change costs you labor and time; for both you and the tire manufacturer, a premium for extra tread life may be beneficial.
Specialist Tires
BF Goodrich offers a superb range of off-road and high-performance tires. These tires are more expensive because they cost more to research and price.
You want to be safe on your off-road adventure, and the last thing you need when miles from a garage is an exploding tire.
Winter tires use more expensive rubber compounds that stay pliable at low temperatures and proportionally more rubber than summer tires.
Warranty Promise vs. Actual Performance
All BF Goodrich tires have a manufacturer’s warranty of up to 50,000 miles for defects. This warranty is average for tires; you can get warranties ranging from 40,000 to 60,000 miles.
The BF Goodrich warranty offers coverage for six years, but even if you don’t do the mileage, it is best practice to change your tires at the five-year mark – tires deteriorate with standing.
You can promote tire longevity by:
- Tire rotation every 10,000 to 15,000 miles for even tread wear.
- Annual tire balancing or every 12,000 miles.
- Wheel alignment – especially if driving off-road, at 15,000-mile intervals.
- Seasonal switch out to winter tires.
- Protecting your tires from UV light while standing.
What Do Drivers Say About BF Goodrich Tires?
Most people do not write a review if their experience of claiming on a warranty is positive. Most reviewers’ complaints center around the following:
- Pro-rated credit for quicker-than-expected tire wear.
- Not getting the total tread mileage.
Positive reviewers on consumeraffairs.com include:
BF Goodrich makes really great tires. Their price is very competitive and I think they are superior to Michelin tires – John of Manahawkin, NJ.
Goodrich tires last longer and perform better than any other tire I have owned. I have driven in mud, snow, rain and ice and have had no problems – Greg of Mannford, OK.
On the negative side, you get:
Tread down to 2/32 after 28,000 miles. Goodrich pro-rates the tires. Needless to say, I’m not getting much credit – Brian of Downers Grove, IL.
I drove approx. Three years on 37,000 miles. The tires hydroplaned in the slightest downpours. The wear is very advanced. I’d never buy a B F Goodrich tire again – Bob of Hudson, Fl.
BF Goodrich Recommended Tires
If a tire has an EU label, then the tire has specified performance in the areas of wet grip braking, fuel efficiency, and noise that you can directly compare across brands.
The snowflake rating tells you that a tire will perform in extreme snow.
Consider the following car types:
| Car Type | Examples | BF Goodrich Tire Recommends |
| Compact Sedan – typical small family car with a petrol engine ls than 1.2L or Diesel 1.5L. | Hyundai Electra; Honda Civic; Audi A3; Toyota Corolla; Volkswagen Jetta; Subaru WRX; Cadillac CT4-V; Kia Forte, Nissan Versa; BMW 4 Series; Tesla Model 3; Nissan Sentra; Mazda 3. | Advantage Control Radial T/A |
| Midsize Sedan – a large family car with internal dimensions of 110-119 cu ft, including passenger area and trunk. | Chevrolet Malibu; Volkswagen Passat; Subaru Legacy; Nissan Altima; Toyota Camry; Kia K5; Hyundai Sonata; Mazda 6; Ford Fusion; Honda Accord. | Advantage Control |
| Compact SUV or CUV | Honda CRV; Hyundai Tucson; Mazda CX-5; Ford Bronco Sport; Subaru Forester; Mitsubishi Outlander; Nissan Rogue; Toyota RAV4. | Trail Terrain T/A Advantage T/A Sport LT |
| Midsize SUV is typically smaller than a full SUV with two or three rows of seats. | Jeep Grand Cherokee; Chevrolet Equinox; Ford Explorer; Toyota Highlander; Lexus RX 350; Honda Pilot; Toyota 4Runner; Kia Sorento; Dodge Journey; Ford Edge. | Trail Terrain T/A Advantage Control |
| Full SUV – basic sports utility vehicle with seating for seven passengers. | Jeep Wagoneer; Ford Expedition; Chevrolet Tahoe; Chevrolet Suburban; GMC Yukon; Toyota Sequoia; Nissan Armada. | Trail Terrain T/A Advantage T/A |
| Pickup trucks | Ford F150; Chevy Silverado 1500; Dodge RAM 1500; Nissan Titan; Toyota Tundra. | All Terrain T/A KO2; Trail Terrain T/A; Mud Terrain T/A KM2 & KM3; Advantage T/A Sport LT, Krawler T/A KX; Commercial T/A All Season. |
Typical performance stats for BF Goodrich recommended tires for typical passenger vehicles are:
| Radial T/A | Advantage Control | Advantage T/A | Trail Terrain T/A | |
| Driving Conditions | Tougher sidewalls. Off-road traction. | All Season. Mud and Snow. | All Season. Mud and Snow. | All Season. Mud and Snow |
| Selling points | Muscle Cars – available with white letters and extra width. Lateral stability. Responsive steering. | Curvilinear grooves give more effective water dispersal and better stopping – up to 8 feet shorter. | Precision steering on wet and snowy surfaces. | Tougher sidewalls. Off road traction. |
| Speed Category | S | V/W/T/H | H, V, T | H, T, S |
| Restrictions | Only legal in the UK for cars registered before 1st October 1990 | |||
| Price per tire | $150 – $160 | $100-$220 | $130-$280 | $165-$380 |
| Rim Sizes | 13″; 14″; 15″ | 14″; 15″; 16″; 17″;18″;19″; 20″ | Fits cars and SUVs (14″ – 22″) | 15″ – 22″ |
| Warranty – treadwear | N/A | 65,000 miles for V and W speed rating | 75,000 for T rating; 60,000 for H and V. | 60,000 miles (T, H) |
| Fuel Efficiency (A-E) | N/A | D | D | E |
| Wet Grip Braking (A-E) | N/A | B | B-C | E |
| Rolling noise | N/A | 69 dB | 69 dB | 72 dB |
| Severe Snow | No | Three Peak Mountain Snowflake rating. | Three Peak Mountain Snowflake rating. | Three Peak Mountain Snowflake rating. |
| Ice traction | No | No | No | No |
Not every tire has an EU label providing third-party confirmation of tire stats and performance. Still, where this information is available, you can directly compare performance between tire brands for fuel efficiency, noise, and wet grip.
Otherwise, it would be best to consider reviews that may be subjective in performance criteria based on a single tire experience.
Comparisons with Other Brands
It is challenging to get an exact comparison of BF Goodrich tires with another brand because tires fit different vehicles and purposes.
All the major tire brands provide an online tire finder guide that narrows your search to the tire they believe best fits your car and driving needs.
Individual manufacturers provide a performance guide rating their tires for fuel economy, wet grip, winter performance, and other factors. But if you read the small print, most manufacturers use other tires in their tire range for comparison.
Your BF Goodrich tire may be the best BF Goodrich tire for wet handling, but that isn’t a comparison with how another brand performs.
Other tire reviews may compile consumer feedback – but this is subjective depending on the number of consumers providing a report. These numbers may be statistically insignificant compared to the many people driving with these tires.
Some tire reviewers may put a tire through its paces for an hour or three months. Again, the report on how the tire performs is highly subjective.
#1 BF Goodrich vs. Michelin
Comparing the recommended tire for crossover SUVs like the Toyota RAV4:
| BF Goodrich Advantage T/A | Michelin Primacy Tour | |
| Price | $130-$280 | $200-$300 |
| Rim Size | 14″ – 22″ | 17″ – 22″ |
| Warranty | 75,000 miles or 60,000 miles, depending on speed rating. | 30,000 to 55,000 miles depending on speed rating. |
| Fuel Efficiency (EU grade A-E) | D | No EU label. No statistics verifying fuel economy. |
| Wet Grip Braking (EU grade A-E) | B-C | No EU label. Tire reviews give it a 3-4 out of five stars for wet handling. |
| Rolling Noise | 69 dB | No EU label. The asymmetric rib pattern aims to reduce road noise. |
| Suitability for Snow | Snowflake rating for extreme snow. | No. |
It is challenging to compare BF Goodrich tires when the Michelin tire doesn’t have an EU rating.
BF Goodrich expects their tires to be more durable as the warranty gives more mileage, and you can rely on the BF Goodrich Advantage T/A tires than the Michelin Primacy Tour in extreme snow.
You will pay less for the BF Goodrich tires and get a more consistent performance.
Comparing tires for a pickup truck like the Ford 150:
| BF Goodrich Trail Terrain | Michelin Defender LTX | |
| Price | $165-$380 | $143 – $466 |
| Rim Size | 15″ – 22″ | 15” – 22” |
| Warranty | 60,000 miles | 50,000 – 70,000 miles |
| Fuel Efficiency (EU grade A-E) | E | No EU label, but the construction is more fuel-efficient than average. |
| Wet Grip Braking (EU grade A-E) | E | No EU label. Reviews indicate excellent wet grip braking. |
| Rolling Noise | 72 dB | No EU label. Tires have polyurethane foam to reduce noise levels. |
| Suitability for Snow | 3PMSF snowflake rated. | Not snowflake rated. |
Unless your driving conditions involve extreme winter weather, there is little to choose between BF Goodrich Trail Terrain and Michelin Defender LTX.
They are competitive in price and have similar performance. But the Michelin Defender LTX is not an all-terrain tire.
If you frequently drive off-road on construction sites or farm tracks, then you are better with BF Goodrich Trail Terrain.
#2 BF Goodrich vs. Bridgestone
Comparing the recommended tire for crossover SUVs like the Toyota RAV4:
| BF Goodrich Advantage T/A | Bridgestone Weatherpeak | |
| Price | $130-$280 | $160 – $270 |
| Rim Size | 14″ – 22″ | 15″ – 20″ |
| Warranty | 75,000 miles or 60,000 miles, depending on speed rating. | 70,000 miles |
| Fuel Efficiency (EU grade A-E) | D | C |
| Wet Grip Braking (EU grade A-E) | B-C | A |
| Rolling Noise | 69 dB | 70 dB |
| Suitability for Snow | 3PMSF Snowflake rated for extreme snow. | 3PMSF Snowflake rated for extreme snow. |
Bridgestone Weatherpeak outperforms BF Goodrich Advantage T/A, but it is slightly noisier and doesn’t fit the same range of rim sizes.
If you can find Bridgestone tires to fit your compact SUV, then Bridgestone tires will cost around the same price and perform significantly better than BF Goodrich.
Comparing tires for a pickup truck like the Ford 150:
| BF Goodrich Trail Terrain | Bridgestone Dueler A/T | |
| Price | $165-$380 | $300- $350 |
| Rim Size | 15″ – 22″ | 16″ – 20″ |
| Warranty | 60,000 miles | 60,000 miles |
| Fuel Efficiency (EU grade A-E) | E | D |
| Wet Grip Braking (EU grade A-E) | E | C |
| Rolling Noise | 72 dB | 72-73 dB |
| Suitability for Snow | 3PMSF snowflake rated. | 3PMSF snowflake rated. |
The BF Goodrich and Bridgestone tires are suitable for off-road activities like construction sites and challenging roads.
Bridgestone Dueler A/T tires outperform BF Goodrich Trail Terrain but are noisier and more expensive in smaller sizes but competitive in larger ones.
The fuel economy and improved wet grip braking mean the Bridgestone tire (if available in your rim size) is the better option, although noisier.
#3 BF Goodrich vs. Goodyear
Comparing the recommended tire for crossover SUVs like the Subaru Forester:
| BF Goodrich Advantage T/A | Goodyear Assurance All Season | |
| Price | $130-$280 | Under $100 to $200 |
| Rim Size | 14″ – 22″ | 14” – 20” |
| Warranty | 75,000 miles or 60,000 miles, depending on speed rating. | 65,000 miles |
| Fuel Efficiency (EU grade A-E) | D | No EU label, but has a low rolling resistance for good fuel efficiency. |
| Wet Grip Braking (EU grade A-E) | B-C | UTQG rated A. |
| Rolling Noise | 69 dB | No EU label, but considered relatively quiet. |
| Suitability for Snow | 3PMSF Snowflake rated for extreme snow. | No. |
BF Goodrich Advantage T/A is your best option if you need tires to cope with extreme winter weather. If you want a budget tire with similar performance, then the Goodyear All Season is suitable for everything except severe snow.
Comparing tires for a pickup truck like the Ford 150:
| BF Goodrich Trail Terrain | Goodyear Wrangler Workhorse | |
| Price | $165-$380 | $170 -$370 |
| Rim Size | 15″ – 22″ | 16″ – 22″ |
| Warranty | 60,000 miles | 50,000 miles |
| Fuel Efficiency (EU grade A-E) | E | No EU label. |
| Wet Grip Braking (EU grade A-E) | E | No EU label, but reviews indicate excellent wet grip. |
| Rolling Noise | 72 dB | No EU label, but reviews indicate relatively quiet. |
| Suitability for Snow | 3PMSF snowflake rated. | 3PMSF snowflake rated. |
BF Goodrich Trail Terrain and Goodyear Wrangler Workhorse tires are suitable for off-road activities like construction sites and challenging roads, and both brands offer similar performance at similar prices.
The warranty on the BF Goodrich tires is better, but otherwise, there is little to differentiate between them.
#4 BF Goodrich vs. Cooper
Comparing the recommended tire for crossover SUVs like the Honda CR-V:
| BF Goodrich Advantage T/A | Cooper Endeavor | |
| Price | $130-$280 | $130- $250 |
| Rim Size | 14″ – 22″ | 15″ – 19″ |
| Warranty | 75,000 miles or 60,000 miles, depending on speed rating. | 65,000 miles |
| Fuel Efficiency (EU grade A-E) | D | No EU label. |
| Wet Grip Braking (EU grade A-E) | B-C | UTQG rated A |
| Rolling Noise | 69 dB | No EU label. Tire reviews don’t indicate they are excessively noisy. |
| Suitability for Snow | 3PMSF Snowflake rated for extreme snow. | No |
Cooper tires are significantly less expensive than BF Goodrich, but you get fewer suitable options and average performance.
If you need tires to cope with extreme snow, you will need to replace Cooper tires with winter tires. If you have severe weather and you don’t want to swap out your tires, BF Goodrich is the better bet.
Comparing tires for a pickup truck like the Ford 150:
| BF Goodrich Trail Terrain | Cooper Discoverer AT3 | |
| Price | $165-$380 | $197 – $400 |
| Rim Size | 15″ – 22″ | 15″ – 22″ |
| Warranty | 60,000 miles | 65,000miles |
| Fuel Efficiency (EU grade A-E) | E | D |
| Wet Grip Braking (EU grade A-E) | E | C |
| Rolling Noise | 72 dB | 73-75 dB |
| Suitability for Snow | 3PMSF snowflake rated. | 3PMSF snowflake rated. |
Cooper Discoverer tires are noisier and more expensive, but they perform better as pickup truck tires than the BF Goodrich equivalent.
#5 BF Goodrich vs. Continental
Comparing the recommended tire for SUVs:
| BF Goodrich Advantage T/A | Continental All Season Contact | |
| Price | $130-$280 | Starts under $100 to about $200 |
| Rim Size | 14″ – 22″ | 13″ – 20″ |
| Warranty | 75,000 miles or 60,000 miles, depending on speed rating. | No treadwear warranty. |
| Fuel Efficiency (EU grade A-E) | D | B-C |
| Wet Grip Braking (EU grade A-E) | B-C | B |
| Rolling Noise | 69 dB | 71-72 dB |
| Suitability for Snow | 3PMSF Snowflake rated for extreme snow. | 3PMSF Snowflake rated for extreme snow. |
The Continental All Season tire performs better than BF Goodrich Advantage T/A and costs less, and it is slightly noisier, but you have limited rim sizes.
However, if your vehicle can fit Continental tires, they are affordable with better than average performance even in extreme snow.
Comparing tires for a pickup truck like the Ford 150:
| BF Goodrich Trail Terrain | Continental All Season Contact | |
| Price | $165-$380 | Starts under $100 to about $200 |
| Rim Size | 15″ – 22″ | 13″ – 20″ |
| Warranty | 60,000 miles | No treadwear warranty. |
| Fuel Efficiency (EU grade A-E) | E | B-C |
| Wet Grip Braking (EU grade A-E) | E | B |
| Rolling Noise | 72 dB | 71-72 dB |
| Suitability for Snow | 3PMSF snowflake rated. | 3PMSF Snowflake rated for extreme snow. |
The Continental All Season is an excellent truck tire – better performing and more affordable than the BF Goodrich Trail Terrain.
#6 BF Goodrich vs. Yokohama
Comparing the recommended tire for crossover SUVs like the Toyota RAV4:
| BF Goodrich Advantage T/A | Yokohama Advan Fleva V701 | |
| Price | $130-$280 | Starts under $100 |
| Rim Size | 14″ – 22″ | 15” – 20” |
| Warranty | 75,000 miles or 60,000 miles, depending on speed rating. | Limited warranty |
| Fuel Efficiency (EU grade A-E) | D | C-D |
| Wet Grip Braking (EU grade A-E) | B-C | A |
| Rolling Noise | 69 dB | A-B (quiet) |
| Suitability for Snow | 3PMSF Snowflake rated for extreme snow. | No |
The Yokohoma Advan Fleva tire has superb wet braking and is competitive in price. The significant disadvantage in comparison with BF Goodrich Advantage T/A is that these strict summer tires as the tires are not for use below 37F.
Comparing tires for a pickup truck like the Ford 150:
| BF Goodrich Trail Terrain | Yokohama Parada Spec-X | |
| Price | $165-$380 | $180 – $500 |
| Rim Size | 15″ – 22″ | 18″ – 24″ |
| Warranty | 60,000 miles | Limited warranty. |
| Fuel Efficiency (EU grade A-E) | E | D |
| Wet Grip Braking (EU grade A-E) | E | B |
| Rolling Noise | 72 dB | 74 dB |
| Suitability for Snow | 3PMSF snowflake rated. | No. |
Besides winter weather and noise, the Yokohama Spec-X truck tire outperforms BF Goodrich Trail Terrain, but you pay a premium for the enhanced performance.
#7 BF Goodrich vs. Falken
Comparing the recommended tire for crossover SUVs like the Toyota RAV4:
| BF Goodrich Advantage T/A | Falken Ziex ZE950 A/S | |
| Price | $130-$280 | $150 – $240 |
| Rim Size | 14″ – 22″ | 15” – 20” |
| Warranty | 75,000 miles or 60,000 miles, depending on speed rating. | 65,000 to 45,000 miles, depending on the speed rating. |
| Fuel Efficiency (EU grade A-E) | D | No EU label, but other Zeix range tires rate C. |
| Wet Grip Braking (EU grade A-E) | B-C | No EU label, but other Zeix range tires rate A. UTQG rating AA. |
| Rolling Noise | 69 dB | No EU label, but other Zeix range tires rate 67 dB. |
| Suitability for Snow | 3PMSF Snowflake rated for extreme snow. | No. |
The Falken tire outperforms BF Goodrich for a similar or lower price. But if you need to deal with severe winter snow, you need BF Goodrich all-season tires or swap out your Falken tires for a winter version.
Comparing tires for a pickup truck like the Ford 150:
| BF Goodrich Trail Terrain | Falken Wildpeak A/T | |
| Price | $165-$380 | $150 – $240 |
| Rim Size | 15″ – 22″ | 15” – 22” |
| Warranty | 60,000 miles | 65,000 miles |
| Fuel Efficiency (EU grade A-E) | E | C-E |
| Wet Grip Braking (EU grade A-E) | E | B-D |
| Rolling Noise | 72 dB | 71 dB |
| Suitability for Snow | 3PMSF snowflake rated. | 3PMSF snow rating |
You pay less and get better performance from Falken Wildpeak than BF Goodrich Trail Terrain, with less noise and a longer warranty.
#8 BF Goodrich vs. Pirelli
Comparing the recommended tire for crossover SUVs like the Toyota RAV4:
| BF Goodrich Advantage T/A | Pirelli Scorpion Verde | |
| Price | $130-$280 | Under $100 to $240 |
| Rim Size | 14″ – 22″ | 16” – 22” |
| Warranty | 75,000 miles or 60,000 miles, depending on speed rating. | Manufacturer limited warranty. |
| Fuel Efficiency (EU grade A-E) | D | C |
| Wet Grip Braking (EU grade A-E) | B-C | B |
| Rolling Noise | 69 dB | 71 dB |
| Suitability for Snow | 3PMSF Snowflake rated for extreme snow. | No |
The BF Goodrich Advantage T/A tire is best in extreme snow; otherwise, the Pirelli Scorpion Verde is more fuel-efficient and cheaper but noisier.
Comparing tires for a pickup truck like the Ford 150:
| BF Goodrich Trail Terrain | Pirelli Scorpion ATR | |
| Price | $165-$380 | $150 – $250 |
| Rim Size | 15″ – 22″ | 14” – 22” |
| Warranty | 60,000 miles | 50,000 miles |
| Fuel Efficiency (EU grade A-E) | E | D-E |
| Wet Grip Braking (EU grade A-E) | E | C-E |
| Rolling Noise | 72 dB | 71-74 dB |
| Suitability for Snow | 3PMSF snowflake rated. | No |
BF Goodrich Trail Terrain offers winter performance and a better warranty, while the Pirelli Scorpion ATR option offers an affordable tire with better fuel efficiency and wet braking.
#9 BF Goodrich vs. Firestone
Comparing the recommended tire for crossover SUVs like the Hyundai Tucson:
| BF Goodrich Advantage T/A | Firestone All Season | |
| Price | $130-$280 | $160 – $220 |
| Rim Size | 14″ – 22″ | 14” – 20” |
| Warranty | 75,000 miles or 60,000 miles, depending on speed rating. | 65,000 miles. |
| Fuel Efficiency (EU grade A-E) | D | D |
| Wet Grip Braking (EU grade A-E) | B-C | B |
| Rolling Noise | 69 dB | 71 dB |
| Suitability for Snow | 3PMSF Snowflake rated for extreme snow. | No. |
The Firestone All Season is noisier and not suitable for extreme snow compared to BF Goodrich Advantage T/A. Otherwise, the two tires are similar in fuel efficiency and braking performance.
Comparing the recommended tires for a pickup truck like the Ford F150:
| BF Goodrich Trail Terrain | Firestone Destination LE3 | |
| Price | $165-$380 | $150 – $250 |
| Rim Size | 15″ – 22″ | 15” – 22” |
| Warranty | 60,000 miles | 70,000 miles |
| Fuel Efficiency (EU grade A-E) | E | No EU label. Firestone scores this as the best for fuel efficiency. |
| Wet Grip Braking (EU grade A-E) | E | No EU label. Firestone scores this in the best zone. |
| Rolling Noise | 72 dB | No EU label. Firestone scores this as quiet and smooth. |
| Suitability for Snow | 3PMSF snowflake rated. | No. |
Firestone Destination LE3 isn’t sold in Europe so it is not possible to compare independent ratings.
The Firestone Destination LE3 truck tire is more affordable and has a better warranty than the BF Goodrich Trail Terrain, although the latter is better suited for driving in the snow.
#10 BF Goodrich vs. Toyo
Comparing the recommended tire for crossover SUVs like the Toyota RAV4:
| BF Goodrich Advantage T/A | Toyo Celsius CUV | |
| Price | $130-$280 | $140 – $290 |
| Rim Size | 14″ – 22″ | 16” – 22” |
| Warranty | 75,000 miles or 60,000 miles, depending on speed rating. | 60,000 miles |
| Fuel Efficiency (EU grade A-E) | D | C-E |
| Wet Grip Braking (EU grade A-E) | B-C | C |
| Rolling Noise | 69 dB | 69-72 dB |
| Suitability for Snow | 3PMSF Snowflake rated for extreme snow. | 3PMSF |
BF Goodrich Advantage T/A performs better and is marginally more affordable than Toyo Celcius CUV.
Comparing tires for a pickup truck like the Ford 150:
| BF Goodrich Trail Terrain | Toyo Open Country A/T III | |
| Price | $165-$380 | $200 – $700 |
| Rim Size | 15″ – 22″ | 15” – 22” |
| Warranty | 60,000 miles | 65,000 miles |
| Fuel Efficiency (EU grade A-E) | E | No EU label, but the AT Plus rates D. |
| Wet Grip Braking (EU grade A-E) | E | No EU label, but the AT Plus rates D. |
| Rolling Noise | 72 dB | No EU label, but the AT Plus rates 70-74 dB. |
| Suitability for Snow | 3PMSF snowflake rated. | 3PMSF snowflake rating |
The extra cost of the Toyo Open Country in comparison to the BF Goodrich Trail Terrain tire does offer improved performance, although both perform in extreme snow.
#11 BF Goodrich vs. Dunlop
Comparing the recommended tire for crossover SUVs like the Honda CR-V:
| BF Goodrich Advantage T/A | Dunlop Winter Sport 5 | |
| Price | $130-$280 | Starts under $100 to $250 |
| Rim Size | 14″ – 22″ | 16″ – 20″ |
| Warranty | 75,000 miles or 60,000 miles, depending on speed rating. | 24 months or 24,000 miles. |
| Fuel Efficiency (EU grade A-E) | D | C-D |
| Wet Grip Braking (EU grade A-E) | B-C | B-D |
| Rolling Noise | 69 dB | 69 dB |
| Suitability for Snow | 3PMSF Snowflake rated for extreme snow. | 3PMSF Snowflake rated for extreme snow. |
Dunlop Winter Sport has comparable performance to the BF Goodrich recommended tire, but it is a winter tire. Ideally, you swap between this tire and a summer tire unless you live in conditions where winter weather is the norm.
The Dunlop Winter Sport is not an off-road tire, so if you need to take your SUV on more challenging trails, opt for BF Goodrich Advantage T/A.
Comparing tires for a pickup truck like the Ford 150:
| BF Goodrich Trail Terrain | Dunlop Grandtrek AT20 | |
| Price | $165-$380 | Around $170 to $300 |
| Rim Size | 15″ – 22″ | 16″ – 18″ |
| Warranty | 60,000 miles | 24 months or 24,000 miles |
| Fuel Efficiency (EU grade A-E) | E | C-D |
| Wet Grip Braking (EU grade A-E) | E | B-D |
| Rolling Noise | 72 dB | A-B (lower than 69 dB) |
| Suitability for Snow | 3PMSF snowflake rated. | No |
Except for severe winter weather, the Dunlop tire performs better than the BF Goodrich equivalent for a similar price – but you are restricted in available rime sizes.
#12 BF Goodrich vs. General Tire
Comparing the recommended tire for crossover SUVs like the Kia Sorento:
| BF Goodrich Advantage T/A | General Tire G-Max A/S | |
| Price | $130-$280 | $116 – $281 |
| Rim Size | 14″ – 22″ | 16” – 22” |
| Warranty | 75,000 miles or 60,000 miles, depending on speed rating. | 50,000 miles |
| Fuel Efficiency (EU grade A-E) | D | No EU label. Reviews indicate improvements in fuel efficiency. |
| Wet Grip Braking (EU grade A-E) | B-C | No EU label. Reviews indicate excellent handling in the wet. |
| Rolling Noise | 69 dB | No EU label. Reviews indicate this it is relatively quiet. |
| Suitability for Snow | 3PMSF Snowflake rated for extreme snow. | No. |
BF Goodrich outperforms its competitors (including General Tire G-Max) by ensuring that its all-season tires cope with extreme snow.
Although you may not need this feature if you live in a temperate climate without significant snowfall, it is a lifesaver in harsh conditions.
Comparing tires for a pickup truck like the Ford 150:
| BF Goodrich Trail Terrain | General Tire Grabber UHP | |
| Price | $165-$380 | $170 – $375 |
| Rim Size | 15″ – 22″ | 16″ – 24″ |
| Warranty | 60,000 miles | Limited – 72 months. |
| Fuel Efficiency (EU grade A-E) | E | E |
| Wet Grip Braking (EU grade A-E) | E | C |
| Rolling Noise | 72 dB | 72-75 dB |
| Suitability for Snow | 3PMSF snowflake rated. | No |
General Tire Grabber UHP performs better if your principal driving need is excellent wet braking. If you need traction on heavy snow, then opt for BF Goodrich.
Otherwise, these two brands provide similar performance for an equivalent price.
Which Tires Are Better Than BF Goodrich?
The comparison is not straightforward – you need to compare the specific tires that fit your vehicle to assess which is best for price and performance accurately.
The suggestions below are possible alternatives that perform better or cost less, but it all depends on the specific tires compared:
- Michelin is potentially more fuel efficient.
- Goodyear, Falken, and Yokohama are potentially better in wet conditions.
- Pirelli may be quieter.
- General Tire, Dunlop, and Firestone are all potentially cheaper to buy than BF Goodrich for equivalent tires.
When Is the Best Time to Buy BF Goodrich Tires?
Tires are generally cheaper in April and October, but the best way to save money on your BF Goodrich tires is to shop around and take excellent care of the tires on your vehicle by keeping your wheels balanced.
Conclusion
BF Goodrich produces excellent tires and is respected for its all-terrain off-road tires.
Individual tires may perform better or worse than the competition and cost more or less, depending on the brand. You can be confident that genuine BF Goodrich tires are road safe and durable.
Your preferred driving style and vehicle may do well with BF Goodrich, but it depends on your preferences and experience.
Some drivers will always opt for BF Goodrich if available, whereas others prefer a higher-performing tire or features like rim protection and runflat technology available with other brands.
References: