Kelly Tires: Are They Any Good? (+15 Brands Compared)
Founded in 1894, Kelly tires are now a subsidiary of Goodyear (since 1935).
How good are the tires? Are they worth buying?
Why Buy Kelly Tires?
Kelly tires are a leading Goodyear brand and are popular with customers for:
- American manufacture – North Carolina.
- Durability with a consistent 60,000 mile.
- Available for a comprehensive vehicle range.
- Excellent traction across a range of driving conditions.
- Tread design reduces the risk of aquaplaning.
Kelly tires give consistent performance, durability, and a safe ride for a reasonable price.
Why Is Kelly Tires So Cheap?
The factors that keep the prices down are:
Local Manufacture and Shared Plant
Kelly Tires are an American brand and a subsidiary of Goodyear. They get savings from reduced distribution and marketing costs.
Plus, there are savings from the purchasing power of being part of a larger group.
Saving on Research and Development
Goodyear determines the level of innovation involved in the Kelly tire range.
Research is expensive, and not having a research team keeps the prices of tires low.
The best practices in tire production trickle down, but no one expects a budget tire to incorporate all the latest advances in tread block design.
No Frills Approach
Kelly tire prices are twice those of its sister budget brand Douglas. The tire formulation is a bit more advanced, and the performance is enhanced in comparison.
Still, the tires focus on the basics – good enough traction in all conditions and good enough durability.
If you are not pushing the performance edges, you can produce a budget tire that is safe and dependable.
Kelly Tire Warranty
Typically, you get a four-year warranty against defects and a limited treadwear warranty of 50-55,000 miles.
Generally, you expect your Kelly tire to last longer than 50,000 miles in standard driving conditions.
Kelly Tire is available globally through discount retailers like Walmart, tire dealerships, and online.
Online retail customers tend to award Kelly tires four or five stars for satisfaction.
Kelly Tire Recommendations
For typical vehicles:
| Car Type | Examples | Kelly Tire Recommends |
| A compact Sedan is a typical small family car with a petrol engine of more than 1.2L or a Diesel of 1.5L. | Hyundai Electra; Honda Civic; Audi A3; Toyota Corolla; Mazda 3. | Kelly Edge A/S; Kelly Edge AT; Kelly Edge HP. |
| Midsize Sedan – a large family car with internal dimensions of 110-119 cuft, including passenger area and trunk. | Chevrolet Malibu; Volkswagen Passat; Subaru Legacy; Nissan Altima; Toyota Camry. | Kelly Edge A/S; Kelly Edge AT; Kelly Edge HP. |
| Compact SUV or CUV | Honda CRV; Nissan Rogue; Toyota RAV4. | Kelly Edge A/S; Kelly Edge MT; Kelly Edge HT. |
| A midsize SUV is typically smaller than a full SUV with two or three rows of seats. | Jeep Grand Cherokee; Chevrolet Equinox; Ford Explorer; Toyota Highlander. | Kelly Edge MT; Kelly Edge HT. |
| Full SUV – basic sports utility vehicle with seating for seven passengers. | Jeep Wagoneer; Ford Expedition; Chevrolet Suburban; Toyota Sequoia. | Kelly Edge MT; Kelly Edge HT. |
| Light Trucks – gross vehicle weight of 8,500lbs | Ford F150; Toyota Tundra; Dodge RAM 1500; Nissan Titan. | Kelly Edge MT; Kelly Edge HT. |
Kelly tire specifications:
| Kelly Edge All Season | Kelly Edge AT | Kelly Edge HT | Kelly Edge MT | Kelly Safari TSR | |
| Driving conditions | All season traction for everyday driving. | All season and all terrain. | All season traction for SUV and light Trucks | Maximum traction for off-road and on highway. | All terrain. All season. |
| Selling points. | Durable and enhanced tread patterns for improved handling. | Durable and off-road traction. | Durable and enhanced tread patterns for improved handling. | Can add studs for winter driving. Best Kelly tire for off-road conditions. | Deep treads for better wet handling. |
| Price per tire | Starts at $83 – $116 | Starts at $140 | Starts at $207 | Starts at $233 | Starts at $150 |
| Rim Sizes | 14”- 18” | 15”- 18” | 16”- 22” | 16”- 22” | 15” – 18” |
| Warranty – treadwear. | 55,000 miles | 50,000 miles | No treadwear warranty | No treadwear warranty | No treadwear warranty |
| Fuel efficiency (A-E) | No details | No details | No details | No details | No EU label |
| Wet Grip braking (A-E) | UTQG rate A | UTQG rate A | UTQG rate A | UTQG rate A | No EU label. Reviewers give 4.5/5 stars for traction in wet and wintry conditions. |
| Rolling noise | No details | No details | No details | No details | No EU label |
| Extreme snow. | No | No | No | No | Not suitable for extreme snow. |
| Ice traction. | No | No | No | No | No |
Comparison with Other Brands
Comparing the Kelly Edge AS (compact SUV) and the Kelly Edge HT (full-size light-duty trucks) with recommended tires from other brands.
#1 Kelly vs. Michelin
Comparing the Kelly Edge AS with the Michelin Cross Climate 2 for crossover SUVs:
You will save $100 or more by choosing Kelly tires. For the extra money, the Michelin tire gives you better fuel efficiency and better handling in wintry conditions.
| Kelly Edge AS | Michelin Cross Climate 2 | |
| Price | $83 – $116 | $170 – $350 |
| Rim Size | 14” – 18” | 15” – 20” |
| Warranty | 55,000 miles | 60,000 miles |
| Fuel Efficiency (EU grade A-E) | No details | B-C |
| Wet Grip Braking (EU grade A-E) | UTQG rated A | B |
| Rolling Noise | No details | 69 dB |
| Suitability for Snow | No | 3PMSF rated. |
Comparing the Kelly Edge HT with the Defender LTX for pickup trucks:
It is worth comparing prices for your tire size because the Michelin tire costs $50 less than the Kelly tire. But you can pay $200 more per tire at larger sizes for the Michelin tire. The performance isn’t dramatically different, but the Michelin tire offers a durable rubber compound compared with the Kelly tire.
| Kelly Edge HT | Michelin Defender LTX | |
| Price | Starts at $207 | $143 – $466 |
| Rim Size | 16” – 22” | 15” – 22” |
| Warranty | No treadwear warranty | 50,000 – 70,000 miles |
| Fuel Efficiency (EU grade A-E) | No details | No EU label, but the construction is more fuel-efficient than average. |
| Wet Grip Braking (EU grade A-E) | UTQG rated A | No EU label. Reviews indicate excellent wet grip braking. |
| Rolling Noise | No details | No EU label. Tires have polyurethane foam to reduce noise levels. |
| Suitability for Snow | No | Not snowflake rated. |
#2 Kelly vs. Firestone
Comparing the Kelly Edge AS with the Firestone All Season for SUVs: You will save at least $80 per tire with the Kelly tire, while the Firestone tire gives you increased durability but comparable performance.
| Kelly Edge AS | Firestone All Season | |
| Price | $83 – $116 | $160 – $220 |
| Rim Size | 14” – 18” | 14” – 20” |
| Warranty | 55,000 miles | 65,000 miles. |
| Fuel Efficiency (EU grade A-E) | No details | D |
| Wet Grip Braking (EU grade A-E) | UTQG rated A | B |
| Rolling Noise | No details | 71 dB |
| Suitability for Snow | No | No. |
Comparing the Kelly Edge HT with the Firestone Destination LE3 for pickup trucks:
The Firestone tire is competitively priced compared with the Kelly. Depending on where you shop, you may pay a few dollars more or less. The Firestone tire is quieter and more durable, so for the same price, you may get further savings on less frequent tire changes.
| Kelly Edge HT | Firestone Destination LE3 | |
| Price | Starts at $207 | $150 – $250 |
| Rim Size | 16” – 22” | 15” – 22” |
| Warranty | No treadwear warranty | 70,000 miles |
| Fuel Efficiency (EU grade A-E) | No details | No EU label. Firestone scores this as the best for fuel efficiency. |
| Wet Grip Braking (EU grade A-E) | UTQG rated A | No EU label. Firestone scores this in the best zone. |
| Rolling Noise | No details | No EU label. Firestone scores this as quiet and smooth. |
| Suitability for Snow | No | No. |
#3 Kelly vs. Goodyear
Comparing the Kelly Edge AS with the Goodyear Assurance All Season for SUVs:
You may save with the Kelly tire or pay about the same price. The Goodyear tire offers a 65,000-mile warranty (Kelly offers 55,000) but similar performance.
| Kelly Edge AS | Goodyear Assurance All Season | |
| Price | $83 – $116 | Under $100 to $200 |
| Rim Size | 14” – 18” | 14” – 20” |
| Warranty | 55,000 miles | 65,000 miles |
| Fuel Efficiency (EU grade A-E) | No details | No EU label, but has a low rolling resistance for good fuel efficiency. |
| Wet Grip Braking (EU grade A-E) | UTQG rated A | UTQG rated A. |
| Rolling Noise | No details | No EU label, but considered relatively quiet. |
| Suitability for Snow | No | No. |
Comparing the Kelly Edge HT with the Wrangler TrailRunner AT for pickup trucks:
Depending on your tire size, you may save money with the Goodyear tire, while the Kelly tire is more affordable in larger sizes. The Goodyear tire performs better, is quieter on the road, more durable, and will take you through a snowy winter and back to spring without needing to change your tires.
Kelly is a subsidiary of Goodyear, so it is not surprising that Goodyear sets the performance differential.
| Kelly Edge HT | Goodyear Wrangler TrailRunner AT | |
| Price | Starts at $207 | $170 – $350 |
| Rim Size | 16” – 22” | 15” – 20” |
| Warranty | No treadwear warranty | 60,000 miles |
| Fuel Efficiency (EU grade A-E) | No details | Exempt class; will vary with loading. |
| Wet Grip Braking (EU grade A-E) | UTQG rated A | Exempt class. Sawtooth design with sipes to increase traction. |
| Rolling Noise | No details | Exempt class. Computer-optimized tread pattern reduces noise. |
| Suitability for Snow | No | 3PMSF winter rating. |
#4 Kelly vs. Bridgestone
Comparing the Kelly Edge AS with the Bridgestone WeatherPeak for SUVs:
You can save as much as $150 per tire by choosing the Kelly tire. The Bridgestone tire offers best in class wet handling, fuel efficiency, and minimal road noise. The Bridgestone tire will also take you through all four seasons if you have snowy winters.
| Kelly Edge AS | Bridgestone WeatherPeak | |
| Price | $83 – $116 | $160 – $270 |
| Rim Size | 14” – 18” | 15″ – 20″ |
| Warranty | 55,000 miles | 70,000 miles |
| Fuel Efficiency (EU grade A-E) | No details | C |
| Wet Grip Braking (EU grade A-E) | UTQG rated A | A |
| Rolling Noise | No details | 70 dB |
| Suitability for Snow | No | 3PMSF Snowflake rated for extreme snow. |
Comparing the Kelly Edge HT with the Bridgestone Dueler A/T for pickup trucks:
You will save at least $100 per tire by switching to Kelly, although the Bridgestone tire is more durable and better in the snow. Otherwise, the performance is not too dissimilar.
| Kelly Edge HT | Bridgestone Dueler A/T | |
| Price | Starts at $207 | $300- $350 |
| Rim Size | 16” – 22” | 16″ – 20″ |
| Warranty | No treadwear warranty | 60,000 miles |
| Fuel Efficiency (EU grade A-E) | No details | D |
| Wet Grip Braking (EU grade A-E) | UTQG rated A | C |
| Rolling Noise | No details | 72-73 dB |
| Suitability for Snow | No | 3PMSF snowflake rated. |
#5 Kelly vs. Continental
Comparing the Kelly Edge AS with the Continental All Season Contact for SUVs: The prices are comparable, so the Continental may be the same or cheaper than the Kelly tire. The performance is similar, but the Continental is the better all-season option if you expect snow in the winter month.
| Kelly Edge AS | Continental All Season Contact | |
| Price | $83 – $116 | Starts under $100 to about $200 |
| Rim Size | 14” – 18” | 13″ – 20″ |
| Warranty | 55,000 miles | No treadwear warranty. |
| Fuel Efficiency (EU grade A-E) | No details | B-C |
| Wet Grip Braking (EU grade A-E) | UTQG rated A | B |
| Rolling Noise | No details | 71-72 dB |
| Suitability for Snow | No | 3PMSF Snowflake rated for extreme snow. |
Comparing the Kelly Edge HT with the Viking Contact 7 for pickup trucks: The Continental tire is cheaper with a 3PMSF rating, but the Kelly brakes better in the wet.
| Kelly Edge HT | Continental Viking Contact 7 | |
| Price | Starts at $207 | $110 – $160 |
| Rim Size | 16” – 22” | 15″ – 22″ |
| Warranty | No treadwear warranty | Two years from date of purchase – not treadwear. |
| Fuel Efficiency (EU grade A-E) | No details | C-D |
| Wet Grip Braking (EU grade A-E) | UTQG rated A | D-E |
| Rolling Noise | No details | 71-72 dB |
| Suitability for Snow | No | 3PMSF snowflake rated. |
#6 Kelly vs. Cooper
Comparing the Kelly Edge AS with the Cooper Endeavor Plus for SUVs: Typically, you can expect to pay $20-$100 more for the Cooper tire, and its performance is comparable to the Kelly rubber.
| Kelly Edge AS | Cooper Endeavor Plus | |
| Price | $83 – $116 | $100 – $260 |
| Rim Size | 14” – 18” | 16” – 22” |
| Warranty | 55,000 miles | 65,000 miles |
| Fuel Efficiency (EU grade A-E) | No details | No EU label |
| Wet Grip Braking (EU grade A-E) | UTQG rated A | No EU label |
| Rolling Noise | No details | No EU label |
| Suitability for Snow | No | No |
Comparing the Kelly Edge HT with the Discoverer AT3 for pickup trucks. You may pay less for the Cooper tire in some sizes, and the Cooper tire is more durable and has better traction on all terrains compared with Kelly Edge HT.
| Kelly Edge HT | Cooper Discoverer AT3 | |
| Price | Starts at $207 | $197 – $400 |
| Rim Size | 16” – 22” | 15” – 22” |
| Warranty | No treadwear warranty | 65,000 miles |
| Fuel Efficiency (EU grade A-E) | No details | D |
| Wet Grip Braking (EU grade A-E) | UTQG rated A | C |
| Rolling Noise | No details | 73-75 dB |
| Suitability for Snow | No | 3PMSF snowflake rated |
#7 Kelly vs. Yokohama
Comparing the Kelly Edge AS with the Advan Fleva V701 for SUVs: You pay about the same for these tires, and the Yokohama performs better – especially for wet braking.
| Kelly Edge AS | Yokohama Advan Fleva V701 | |
| Price | $83 – $116 | Starts under $100 |
| Rim Size | 14” – 18” | 15” – 20” |
| Warranty | 55,000 miles | Limited warranty |
| Fuel Efficiency (EU grade A-E) | No details | C-D |
| Wet Grip Braking (EU grade A-E) | UTQG rated A | A |
| Rolling Noise | No details | A-B (quiet) |
| Suitability for Snow | No | No |
Comparing the Kelly Edge HT with the Geolander A/T G015 for pickup trucks: The price is similar, and the Yokohama tire gives you better handling in all seasons and greater durability than Kelly.
| Kelly Edge HT | Yokohama Geolandar A/T G015 | |
| Price | Starts at $207 | $100 – $250 |
| Rim Size | 16” – 22” | 15” – 22” |
| Warranty | No treadwear warranty | 60,000 miles |
| Fuel Efficiency (EU grade A-E) | No details | E |
| Wet Grip Braking (EU grade A-E) | UTQG rated A | C |
| Rolling Noise | No details | 71 dB |
| Suitability for Snow | No | 3PMSF snowflake rated |
#8 Kelly vs. Hankook
Comparing the Kelly Edge AS with the Ventus S1 EVO3 for SUVs: Kelly tires are the cheaper option, but the Hankook tire offers better performance and run-on-flat technology for enhanced road safety.
| Kelly Edge AS | Hankook Ventus S1 EVO3 | |
| Price | $83 – $116 | $150 – $250 |
| Rim Size | 14” – 18” | 17” – 22” |
| Warranty | 55,000 miles | 50,000 miles |
| Fuel Efficiency (EU grade A-E) | No details | A |
| Wet Grip Braking (EU grade A-E) | UTQG rated A | B |
| Rolling Noise | No details | 69-70 dB |
| Suitability for Snow | No | No |
Comparing the Kelly Edge HT with the Dynapro AT2 for pickup trucks: You pay about the same as the Kelly tire but get more from the Hankook tire.
| Kelly Edge HT | Hankook Dynapro AT2 | |
| Price | Starts at $207 | $250 – $300 |
| Rim Size | 16” – 22” | 15” – 20” |
| Warranty | No treadwear warranty | 60,000 miles |
| Fuel Efficiency (EU grade A-E) | No details | C-D |
| Wet Grip Braking (EU grade A-E) | UTQG rated A | D |
| Rolling Noise | No details | 73 dB |
| Suitability for Snow | No | 3PMSF rated. |
#9 Kelly vs. Pirelli
Comparing the Kelly Edge AS with the Scorpion Verde for SUVs: Typically, the Pirelli tire will cost more than Kelly but not always. The Pirelli tire offers run-on-flat, more sustainable materials, and better fuel efficiency.
| Kelly Edge AS | Pirelli Scorpion Verde | |
| Price | $83 – $116 | Under $100 to $240 |
| Rim Size | 14” – 18” | 16” – 22” |
| Warranty | 55,000 miles | Manufacturer limited warranty. |
| Fuel Efficiency (EU grade A-E) | No details | C |
| Wet Grip Braking (EU grade A-E) | UTQG rated A | B |
| Rolling Noise | No details | 71 dB |
| Suitability for Snow | No | No |
Comparing the Kelly Edge HT with the Scorpion ATR for pickup trucks: You may pay the same or less than the Kelly tire, but the Pirelli tire gives better performance.
| Kelly Edge HT | Pirelli Scorpion ATR | |
| Price | Starts at $207 | $150 – $250 |
| Rim Size | 16” – 22” | 14” – 22” |
| Warranty | No treadwear warranty | 50,000 miles |
| Fuel Efficiency (EU grade A-E) | No details | D-E |
| Wet Grip Braking (EU grade A-E) | UTQG rated A | C-E |
| Rolling Noise | No details | 71-74 dB |
| Suitability for Snow | No | No |
#10 Kelly vs. Falken
Comparing the Kelly Edge AS with the Ziex ZE950 for SUVs: The Kelly tire is cheaper, but the Falken tire is quieter and a better performer.
| Kelly Edge AS | Falken Ziex ZE950 | |
| Price | $83 – $116 | $150 – $240 |
| Rim Size | 14” – 18” | 15” – 20” |
| Warranty | 55,000 miles | 65,000 to 45,000 miles, depending on the speed rating. |
| Fuel Efficiency (EU grade A-E) | No details | No EU label, but other Zeix range tires rate C. |
| Wet Grip Braking (EU grade A-E) | UTQG rated A | No EU label, but other Zeix range tires rate A. UTQG rating AA. |
| Rolling Noise | No details | No EU label, but other Zeix range tires rate 67 dB. |
| Suitability for Snow | No | No. |
Comparing the Kelly Edge HT with the WildPeak A/T for pickup trucks: You can pay more and less for the Kelly tire, while the Falken tire performs similarly but is more durable and copes better with winter weather.
| Kelly Edge HT | Falken WildPeak A/T | |
| Price | Starts at $207 | $150 – $240 |
| Rim Size | 16” – 22” | 15” – 22” |
| Warranty | No treadwear warranty | 65,000 miles |
| Fuel Efficiency (EU grade A-E) | No details | C-E |
| Wet Grip Braking (EU grade A-E) | UTQG rated A | B-D |
| Rolling Noise | No details | 71 dB |
| Suitability for Snow | No | 3PMSF snow rating |
#11 Kelly vs. Kumho
Comparing the Kelly Edge AS with the Crugen HP71 for SUVs: You will save more than $50 per tire with Kelly, but the Kumho tire offers better performance and durability.
| Kelly Edge AS | Kumho Crugen HP71 | |
| Price | $83 – $116 | Starts at $142 |
| Rim Size | 14” – 18” | 16” – 22” |
| Warranty | 55,000 miles | 65,000 miles |
| Fuel Efficiency (EU grade A-E) | No details | No details |
| Wet Grip Braking (EU grade A-E) | UTQG rated A | Kumho scores 9/10 wet, 8.5/10 dry. |
| Rolling Noise | No details | Kumho scores 9.5/10 |
| Suitability for Snow | No | Kumho scores 8/10 |
Comparing the Kelly Edge HT with the Road Venture AT52 for pickup trucks: You pay less for the Kumho tire and get comparable performance to the Kelly tire and better handling in winter conditions.
| Kelly Edge HT | Kumho Road Venture AT52 | |
| Price | Starts at $207 | Starts at $173 |
| Rim Size | 16” – 22” | 15” – 20” |
| Warranty | No treadwear warranty | 50,000 – 55,000 miles |
| Fuel Efficiency (EU grade A-E) | No details | No details |
| Wet Grip Braking (EU grade A-E) | UTQG rated A | Kumho scores 7/10 for wet and dry. |
| Rolling Noise | No details | Kumho scores 6/10 |
| Suitability for Snow | No | Kumho scores 8/10. Has 3PMSF rating. |
#12 Kelly vs. General Tire
Comparing the Kelly Edge AS with the G-Max AS for SUVs: You can save between $40 and $100 with the Kelly tire and have better braking performance than the General Tire equivalent.
| Kelly Edge AS | General Tire G-Max AS | |
| Price | $83 – $116 | $116 – $281 |
| Rim Size | 14” – 18” | 16” – 22” |
| Warranty | 55,000 miles | 50,000 miles |
| Fuel Efficiency (EU grade A-E) | No details | No EU label. Reviews indicate improvements in fuel efficiency. |
| Wet Grip Braking (EU grade A-E) | UTQG rated A | No EU label. Reviews indicate excellent handling in the wet. |
| Rolling Noise | No details | No EU label. Reviews indicate this it is relatively quiet. |
| Suitability for Snow | No | No. |
Comparing the Kelly Edge HT with the Grabber HTS for pickup trucks: Either of these tires may be the lower price. The Grabber HTS is more durable than Kelly Edge HT but is a three-season rather than a four-season tire.
| Kelly Edge HT | General Tire Grabber HTS | |
| Price | Starts at $207 | $150 – $380 |
| Rim Size | 16” – 22” | 16” – 22” |
| Warranty | No treadwear warranty | 65,000 limited warranty |
| Fuel Efficiency (EU grade A-E) | No details | D |
| Wet Grip Braking (EU grade A-E) | UTQG rated A | D |
| Rolling Noise | No details | 71-72 dB |
| Suitability for Snow | No | No. |
#13 Kelly vs. Douglas
Comparing the Kelly Edge AS with the Douglas All Season for SUVs:
The Douglas tire is a budget tire at half the price of Kelly tires. The performance is comparable, and the Douglas tire is cheaper because Goodyear has set up the tire range as two different budget tires.
| Kelly Edge AS | Douglas All Season | |
| Price | $83 – $116 | $37 – $96 |
| Rim Size | 14” – 18” | 13” – 18” |
| Warranty | 55,000 miles | 45,000 miles |
| Fuel Efficiency (EU grade A-E) | No details | No details. |
| Wet Grip Braking (EU grade A-E) | UTQG rated A | No EU label. UTQG rated A. |
| Rolling Noise | No details | No details. |
| Suitability for Snow | No | No. |
Comparing the Kelly Edge HT with the Douglas Performance for pickup trucks: Douglas tires are half the price of Kely tires with similar performance.
| Kelly Edge HT | Douglas Performance | |
| Price | Starts at $207 | $95 – $108 |
| Rim Size | 16” – 22” | 15” – 18” |
| Warranty | No treadwear warranty | 45,000 miles |
| Fuel Efficiency (EU grade A-E) | No details | No details |
| Wet Grip Braking (EU grade A-E) | UTQG rated A | No EU label. UTQG rated A. |
| Rolling Noise | No details | No details |
| Suitability for Snow | No | No |
#14 Kelly vs. Nexen
Comparing the Kelly Edge AS with the Roadian GTX for SUVs: You will pay at least $50 less per tire with Kelly tires, while the Roadian GTX is more durable and offers better performance.
| Kelly Edge AS | Nexen Roadian GTX | |
| Price | $83 – $116 | Starts at $150 |
| Rim Size | 14” – 18” | 17” – 22” |
| Warranty | 55,000 miles | 70,000 miles |
| Fuel Efficiency (EU grade A-E) | No details | Nexen rating 9/10 |
| Wet Grip Braking (EU grade A-E) | UTQG rated A | UTQG AA (best rating). Nexen rating 8/10 |
| Rolling Noise | No details | Nexen rating 10/10 |
| Suitability for Snow | No | Nexen rating 6/10 |
Comparing the Kelly Edge HT with the Roadian MTX for pickup trucks: You save at least $40 with the Kelly tire and get a similar performance to the Nexen.
| Kelly Edge HT | Nexen Roadian MTX | |
| Price | Starts at $207 | Starts at $257 |
| Rim Size | 16” – 22” | 15” – 22” |
| Warranty | No treadwear warranty | No treadwear warranty |
| Fuel Efficiency (EU grade A-E) | No details | Nexen rating 6/10 |
| Wet Grip Braking (EU grade A-E) | UTQG rated A | Nexen rating 8/10 |
| Rolling Noise | No details | Nexen rating 7/10 |
| Suitability for Snow | No | No. |
#15 Kelly vs. BF Goodrich
Comparing the Kelly Edge AS with the BF Goodrich Advantage TA for SUVs:
You will save at least $50 per tire with Kelly, but the BF Goodrich tire is significantly quieter, more durable, and will perform better in winter weather.
| Kelly Edge AS | BF Goodrich Advantage TA | |
| Price | $83 – $116 | $130-$280 |
| Rim Size | 14” – 18” | 14″ -22″ |
| Warranty | 55,000 miles | 75,000 miles or 60,000 miles, depending on speed rating. |
| Fuel Efficiency (EU grade A-E) | No details | D |
| Wet Grip Braking (EU grade A-E) | UTQG rated A | B-C |
| Rolling Noise | No details | 69 dB |
| Suitability for Snow | No | 3PMSF Snowflake rated for extreme snow. |
Comparing the Kelly Edge HT with the Trail Terrain T/A for pickup trucks:
Sometimes you save with BF Goodrich, and sometimes you save with Kelly – it depends on the tire. The performance is comparable, but the BF Goodrich is better if part of your year includes snow.
| Kelly Edge HT | BF Goodrich Trail Terrain T/A | |
| Price | Starts at $207 | $165-$380 |
| Rim Size | 16” – 22” | 15″ -22″ |
| Warranty | No treadwear warranty | 60,000 miles |
| Fuel Efficiency (EU grade A-E) | No details | E |
| Wet Grip Braking (EU grade A-E) | UTQG rated A | E |
| Rolling Noise | No details | 72 dB |
| Suitability for Snow | No | 3PMSF snowflake rated. |
Alternatives to Kelly Tires
Kelly Tire is a budget offering, but its sister brand, Douglas tires, is half the price.
Other comparable tires for price and potentially better performance include Nokian, Yokohama, and Dunlop.
If you prefer a more fuel-efficient tire, try Dunlop, Hankook, and Nexen. If you want a little more for your money Dunlop and Pirelli offer tires that run on flat and enhance road safety for very little extra cash.
Conclusion
Kelly Tires are a budget brand that costs a little more but offers additional durability than the lowest-priced tire on the market.
It is a no-frills brand and faces competition from lower-priced new tire manufacturers that offer more innovative features.
You get a competitively priced, reliable tire with an excellent history of delivering adequate on and off-road performance.
References: